Why the obvious answer is wrong

  • The obvious answer is 0.67. The filter shows 0.75.
  • Malus's law: part = cos²(angle). cos(30°) ≈ 0.866, and 0.866 × 0.866 ≈ 0.75.
  • The filter keeps cos(angle) of the vibration, and energy goes with the square of its size.
  • At 45° both give 0.50, so one check at 45° hides the error.
  • The event does not use this equation. The lesson is for every question: the obvious way is not always the right way, so check it at a second value.
Two lines of the part of the light that gets through a filter, over the angle between the light and the slots, from 0° to 90°. The dashed straight line is the guess: 0.67 at 30°, 0.50 at 45° and 0.33 at 60°. The curve is Malus's law: 0.75 at 30°, 0.50 at 45° and 0.25 at 60°. The two lines meet at 0°, 45° and 90°.0°30°45°60°90°00.51Angle to the lightPart that gets through0.750.670.500.330.25Malus's lawStraight line
Slide 10 of 24: Why the obvious answer is wrong
main fb25b7f